Banks are plotting 800 more branch closures (2024)

New rules designed to ensure communities will still have access to cash when their last bank shuts are likely to result in a fierce consumer backlash in the coming weeks as some of the country's major high street banks embark upon a fresh round of branch closures.

Banking experts believe the new requirements, thrashed out late last year by the big banks and the Access to Cash Action Group, are well merited, but currently remain far too lenient towards the banks.

Many communities, they argue, will still lose their last bank branch – without benefiting from any improvement in alternative access-to-cash services (a post office for example) that they thought the rules were designed to ensure.

Sign of the times: Closures have become a familiar sight as major banks axed branches in their droves

Banking experts believe between 700 and 800 branches are likely to be culled this year as the major banks seek to cut costs and attempt to stem the march of new digital banks.

The first announcements of the year on bank branch closures are expected to come this month or next – with Lloyds and NatWest rumoured to be closest to confirming their plans.

RELATED ARTICLES

  • Previous
  • 1
  • Next
  • JEFF PRESTRIDGE: Banking hub plan to preserve nationwide... RACHEL RICKARD STRAUS: Life's whizzing by... unless you're... After TSB unleashes another wave of branch closures:At last... You too can fight back! We saved the pub, shop, library and...

Share this article

Share

53 shares

HOW THIS IS MONEY CAN HELP

  • Best savings rates: Compare branch and online savings accounts

'There are going to be a lot of disappointed small businesses and angry branch-dependent customers out there once branch closures start getting announced,' said one banking source close to the new arrangements.

They added: 'As a result of the new rules, they are going to think a white knight will come rushing to their rescue and insist that the banks fund the installation of a new cash machine in their community – or even a new-style banking hub that all bank customers can use. But it won't always be the case.'

Showaddywaddy star: Towns like mine must get support they need

Plea: Music star Dave Bartram

The market town of Syston in Leicestershire will host one of five banking hubs to be launched this year as a result of an agreement struck late last year with the banks and the Access to Cash Action Group.

These will complement any hubs recommended by Link in response to last bank in town closures announced this year.

Syston has lost all of its four banks in the past decade. NatWest exited eight years ago, followed by HSBC,Barclays and Santander, which pulled the plug last summer. Walk down the high street today and the Santander and Barclays branches are boarded up, while NatWest is home to a firm of solicitors and HSBC has become an optician.

The old Barclays branch is currently an eyesore, white paint peeling off the dilapidated building. Yetit is expected to be home to the banking hub by the summer.

Dave Bartram, former frontman of 1970s pop group Showaddywaddy, grew up in this 13,000-strong town and regularly comes back to visit close family and friends.

The 69-year-old, who now lives near Bingham, Nottinghamshire, says news of the banking hub is 'welcome'. Yet he believes banks have helped damage the fabric of many communities like Syston byshutting branches, often indiscriminately.

He says: 'In the music business, if you fail to deliver you do not last. The banking world seems to play by different rules. We trust them with our money and in return get precious little back. Banks should not reward our loyalty to them with branch closures, but show their support for communities like Syston.'

Husein Jamaly, owner of Syston DIY and Hardware store, is equallyunimpressed.

The 56-year-old says: 'Since the banks started pulling out of this town, the footfall for local shops in the area has fallen by more than a third – as people have gone to other nearby towns for their banking needs. I fear this new idea is no substitute for a traditional high street bank.'

Shirley Wright and Lindsay Rook run the Let's Party shop across the road from Husein's business, selling everything from helium-filledballoons to greetings cards.

Shirley, 63, says: 'It is a shame the high street banks have deserted us. The town continues to grow, it's a great place to live, and the economy is buoyed by being home to food company Pukka Pies. Of course, we welcome a new banking hub.'

The other four hubs will be in Acton, West London; Brixham, Devon; Carnoustie, Angus; and Knaresborough, North Yorkshire.

Toby Walne

<!- - ad: https://mads.dailymail.co.uk/v8/us/money/moneysaving/article/other/mpu_factbox.html?id=mpu_factbox_1 - ->

Experts also believe the new rules need the backing of supporting legislation, otherwise the banks will look at ways to comply with them while spending as little as possible on funding alternative banking services.

The Government said it would legislate to protect access to cash two years ago, with any subsequent rules enforced by the Financial Conduct Authority,but it has yet to do so.

Derek French, a longstanding campaigner for shared branches or banking hubs as they are now referred to, says: 'The new rules do not represent a big enough leap forward.

'The banks should be required by legislation to be doing more to preserve banking services on our country's high streets. That means a nationwide network of banking hubs funded by the big banks, not a pick 'n' mix assortment of cash machines and cashback services.'

French says there are between 200 and 400 communities up anddown the country that should be homes to these hubs, but he doubts whether the new rules will result in any more than 30 being set up.

The new rules on closures came into force at the start of this year. They were devised by the Access to Cash Action Group, a committee chaired by 'cash champion' Natalie Ceeney and set up by banking trade association UK Finance to look at ways of preserving access to cash.

The rules require 'independent' oversight of all branch closures ahead of their announcement by an individual bank. This role has been given to cash machine network Link – which is actually owned bythe banks.

If a bank has drawn up a list of closures, it must submit them first to Link. It then applies an algorithm, devised by the banks, to all the branch closures that will leave a community bankless. Closures in towns where there is a rival bank still on the high street will not be investigated.

This algorithm will then determine whether the closure is allowed to take place without any remedial action from the banking industry.

Or it could signal that the closure can happen only if the banks collectively fund the provision of alternative access-to-cash services in the community – or improvements to existing ones. These could take the form of a new free-to-use cash machine, a bolstering of the local post office service (for example, the installation of an extra counter), or a banking hub.

The hub would be operated by a third party such as the Post Office, with staff from the big banks coming in on specific days to meet customers who need to discuss more complex financial issues, such as arranging a home loan or dealing with probate.

Such hubs have already been successfully trialled in Rochford, Essex and Cambuslang near Glasgow. The algorithm takes into account a host of factors indeciding whether alternative banking services need to be provided or existing ones improved.

These include the age demographic of the community – those with a large elderly population will be looked upon more favourably because such an age group has a greater need for high street banking services.

Other factors considered include whether the community has a big network of small cash-generating businesses that need to bank takings on a regular basis; whether the local post office can cope with an increase in demand for its services once the last bank shuts; and theproximity of the nearest town with a remaining bank branch.

Once the algorithm identifies those communities needing new banking services to make up for the loss of the last branch, Link's role will be to determine which of the three solutions is best.

It has put together a small team to visit the communities and assess what is the best way forward. The banks will then be required to carry out and fund Link's recommendation.

It is the fairness of the algorithm that some experts are questioning. They believe it has been set up to minimise the costs that the banks must pay.

It will also not be applied to communities that have already lost their last bank – and there is nothing to stop a bank shutting the last branch, even if a banking hub is recommended by Link and the closing branch would be the best place for it to be located in.

Some believe it will be Link that will end up taking the criticismwhen communities losing their last branch feel short-changed – not the banks. 'The rules aren't good enough,' said one source last week.

'Link will be seen as the ultimate decision maker and will take the flak when it's the banks that should be getting it.'

When a bank announces details of its closures, Link will be allowed to publish shortly afterwards which of the closures it has identified as requiring additional banking services.

The MoS understands some of the banks have already submitted closure lists to Link ahead of official announcements. Yet none of the banks, nor Link representatives, would confirm this.

Lloyds said: 'As we continue to respond to our customers' changing behaviour, and make sure that we have the right branches in the right places, we expect that we will continue to make changes to our branch network. Any potential closures across our brands will go through the independent assessment process, which is an important step in maintaining access to cash for people and businesses who need it.'

NatWest said: 'Having helped to design and develop the industry framework to ensure continued widespread access to cash through the Access to Cash Action Group, we are fully supportive, committed to its requirements, and an active participant in the group.'

Nationwide told The Mail on Sunday: 'Branches remain a key part of the way we serve our members and we recognise how much they are valued. This doesn't mean we will never close a branch – sometimes we have to, for example where we have a number of branches in the same area or a branch requires a lot of financial investment.'

Santander stated: 'We haven't submitted a list [to Link] as we don't have any announcement [on branch closures] planned.' It shut 111 branches last year.

John Howells, Link chief executive, said: 'I am pleased Link has been asked to take on the role of maintaining access to cash and we have our sleeves rolled up to support communities across the UK. Cash use continues to decline, which is placing pressure on ATMs and bank branches.'

Natalie Ceeney said: 'Access to cash and banking services are really important for millions of people and to small businesses. If a community does lose its last branch, there's now an effective way to make sure no one is left behind.

'Whether that's a new ATM, an enhanced Post Office or a banking hub, we have the tools to support communities.'

THIS IS MONEY PODCAST

  • Do Labour or the Tories have the plan Britain needs?
  • What does it take to win the Premium Bonds?
  • The consumer champion's tricks to fight back
  • What could the general election mean for your money?
  • The mystery of the stolen Nectar Points - and the loyalty sting
  • Should BofE have cut interest rates instead of holding firm?
  • Mortgage rates are climbing again - should we be worry?
  • Is the UK stock market finally due its moment in the sun?
  • Will inflation fall below 2% and then spike again?
  • Will the state pension ever be means tested - and would you get it?
  • Secrets from an Isa millionaire - how they built a £1m pot
  • Is a 99% mortgage really that bad or a helping hand?
  • How to sort your pension and Isa before the tax year ends
  • Will the Bank of England cut interest rates soon?
  • Was the Budget too little, too late - and will it make you richer?
  • Tale of the state pension underpaid for 20 YEARS
  • Will the Budget cut tax - and the child benefit and 60% traps?
  • Will you be able to afford the retirement you want?
  • Does it matter that the UK is in recession?
  • Why would the Bank of England cut rates this year?
  • You can bag a £10k heat pump discount... would that tempt you?
  • Should you stick cash in Premium Bonds, save or invest?
  • Is the taxman really going after Ebay sellers?
  • What does 2024 hold for investors - and was 2023 a good year?
  • How fast will interest rates fall - and where's the new normal?
  • Is the mortgage crisis over?
  • What drives you mad about going to the shops?
  • Will the Autumn Statement boost your wealth?
  • How to turn your work pension into a moneyspinner
  • Autumn Statement: What would you do if you were Chancellor?
  • Have interest rates finally peaked - and what happens next?
  • How much will frozen income tax bands suck out of your pay?
  • How much further could house prices fall?
  • Will your energy bills rise this winter despite a falling price cap?
  • Have interest rates peaked or will they rise again?
  • Should we keep the triple lock or come up with a better plan?
  • Should we gift every newborn £1,000 to invest?
  • Are you on track for a comfortable retirement?
  • Where would YOU put your money for the next five years?
  • Mortgage mayhem has stalled but what happens next?
  • Taxman customer service troubles and probate problems
  • Energy firms rapped for bad service while making mega profits
  • Inflation eases - what does that mean for mortgage and savers?
  • Could your bank close YOUR current account with little warning?
  • Energy price cap falling and savings rates race past 6%
  • Was hiking rates again the right move or is the Bank in panic mode?
  • Mortgage mayhem, savings frenzy: What on earth is going on?
  • Money for nothing: Is universal basic income a good idea?
  • Inflation-busting savings rates of 9% and cash Isas are back
  • When will energy bills fall, and could fixed tariffs finally return?
  • Should we stop dragging more into tax designed for the rich?
  • How high will interest rates go... and why are they still rising?
  • How can we build the homes we need - and make them better?
  • Home improvements: How to add - or lose - value
  • It's easier to win big on Premium Bonds but should you invest?
  • How long should you fix your mortgage for - and what next?
  • State pension goes above £10,000 - has something got to give?
  • April bill hikes - and is it time we ditched the tax traps?
  • Pensions, childcare, bills and recession: Budget special
  • Can you trust the state pension system after these blunders?
  • Are we on the verge of a house price crash or soft landing?
  • How to make the most of saving and investing in an Isa
  • Why is food inflation so high and are we being ripped off?
  • Could this be the peak for interest rates? What it means for you
  • Will we raise state pension age to 68 sooner than planned?
  • Could an Isa tax raid really cap savings at £100,000?
  • Will you be able to afford the retirement you want?
  • Will 2023 be a better year for our finances... or worse?
  • The big financial events of 2022 and what happens next?
  • Would you be tempted to 'unretire' after quitting work early?
  • When will interest rates stop rising and how will it affect you?
  • Could house prices really fall 20% and how bad would that be?
  • Do you need to worry about tax on savings and investments?
  • Have savings and mortgage rates already peaked?

Previous

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • 14
  • 15
  • 16
  • 17
  • 18
  • 19
  • 20
  • 21
  • 22
  • 23
  • 24

Next

Some links in this article may be affiliate links. If you click on them we may earn a small commission. That helps us fund This Is Money, and keep it free to use. We do not write articles to promote products. We do not allow any commercial relationship to affect our editorial independence.

Banks are plotting 800 more branch closures (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Mr. See Jast

Last Updated:

Views: 6186

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Mr. See Jast

Birthday: 1999-07-30

Address: 8409 Megan Mountain, New Mathew, MT 44997-8193

Phone: +5023589614038

Job: Chief Executive

Hobby: Leather crafting, Flag Football, Candle making, Flying, Poi, Gunsmithing, Swimming

Introduction: My name is Mr. See Jast, I am a open, jolly, gorgeous, courageous, inexpensive, friendly, homely person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.