Best Pizza in Sea Isle (Updated Fall 2023) - Pizza Oven Radar (2024)

I’ve been all over the world, tasting pizza from humble street vendors and fancy pizzerias alike. But out of the 12 pizza places I’ve tried here in Sea Isle, some stand out as particularly delicious.

It’s not an easy job deciding which pizza place to recommend, but after much research and eating more than my fair share of pizza slices, I’m ready to present my picks for the best pizza in Sea Isle. And trust me, you can’t go wrong with any of these options.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Zio Niccolo Pizza

The first thing I noticed when walking into Zio Niccolo Pizza was the incredible smell of freshly-made dough combined with hints of parmesan cheese and oregano. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, with plenty of seating for small groups or large parties.

The pizza itself was mouthwatering! They use fresh ingredients, like vine-ripened tomatoes, mozzarella cheese and homemade sauce. Every bite was delectable.

The prices are reasonable, the staff friendly and helpful. I even got to chat with the pizzaiolo, who had been baking pizzas since he was a kid! He knows his job well and it shows in the end product.

My experience at Zio Niccolo Pizza left me convinced that it is indeed the best pizza in Sea Isle. I highly recommend you try their amazing pies if you ever happen to be in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Wildwood!

#2 Spinners Pizza

From the moment I stepped into Spinners Pizza, I knew I was in for a treat. The decor is charming and inviting, with colorful decorations and pizza-themed art adorning the walls. The staff are friendly and helpful, quick to make recommendations based on your individual taste – my favorite being their signature spinach and feta pizza.

The pizza here is truly out of this world! It has a light, crispy crust that’s perfectly cooked with just the right amount of crunch. The toppings are generous and always high quality with no skimping on flavor. Plus, you can choose from an array of specialties like margherita pizzas or even custom creations!

I highly recommend Spinners Pizza if you’re looking for the best pizza in Sea Isle. The place has it all – great atmosphere, awesome food, and friendly service that will have you coming back for more!

#3 Basilicos Ristorante-Pizzeria

I have never seen an array of toppings like this place offers. Not only did they have the classics like pepperoni and sausage, but they also featured unique items like clams, artichokes, and arugula. I couldn’t help but try a few slices with these toppings to taste the unique flavor combination.

The pizza crust was perfectly thin and crispy. It was seasoned just right too – not too salty or bland. The sauce was the perfect balance of sweet and tangy and worked perfectly with the toppings I chose.

One thing I absolutely loved about this place is that they had a great selection of craft beers to pair with my pizza! For some reason, it made the slice taste even better than without one.

I would definitely recommend Basilicos Ristorante-Pizzeria for anyone looking for some truly great pizza in Sea Isle. After all, it’s really not hard to see why this place has been recognized as having some of the best pizza in town!

#4 Berardi Brothers Pizza

From the moment I stepped through their door, I knew this was going to be an experience like no other. The décor was slightly rustic, with a modern twist – which really set the tone for their delicious and unique pizzas.

The staff were so friendly and they welcomed me like an old friend – there’s definitely a family vibe in the air here! And boy, do they know how to make a damn good pizza. The ingredients were top-notch and cooked to perfection. The crust was thin and crispy, with just the right amount of crunch on each bite. Their signature sauce was surprisingly balanced, adding a hint of tanginess that made it all come together perfectly.

As far as toppings go, Berardi Brothers Pizza has some of the most creative options around – from their classic Margherita to their Prosciutto and Arugula masterpiece. No matter what you choose here, you’re sure to get a great tasting pizza that will leave your taste buds begging for more!

In short, Berardi Brothers Pizza is easily one of the best pizzerias in Sea Isle. If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, look no further than these brothers!

#5 Sole

When I first walked in, the atmosphere caught my eye. The walls are adorned with fun and funky decorations, and the staff is cheerful and welcoming.

The menu offers a variety of options, including thin crust, deep dish and stuffed pizza. The flavors range from classic to creative, so everyone can find something they like. I chose the Spinach Pesto Pizza and it was absolutely delicious! Every bite had the perfect balance of flavors.

The overall experience at Sole was excellent – from the service to the food – everything was top-notch! So if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Sea Isle, then check out Sole!

#6 Panzinis Pizza House – Sea Isle City

The atmosphere is inviting and the decor is contemporary and fun, making it a great place to kick back with friends and share some pizza. The menu had a wide variety of options ranging from classic Italian favorites like marinara and margherita to more adventurous takes on pizzas like Philly Cheesesteak and Mac & Cheese. All the pies were expertly crafted with just the right doses of sauce and cheese, so I never felt overwhelmed by too much of either.

The staff at Panzinis was friendly and attentive, always eager to chat about their favorite toppings or offer helpful suggestions if I didn’t know what I wanted. And let me tell you – you’re going to want one of everything because each slice was delightful! Plus, the prices were surprisingly affordable for the quality of food being served, so every bite was worth it.

Overall, Panzinis Pizza House – Sea Isle City is easily in my top five favorite pizza places in the world. If you’re ever in town looking for some authentic Italian flavor, this is definitely where you should go!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Wildwood Crest!

#7 Azzurra Pizza

The atmosphere of this restaurant is wonderful. It has a cozy, Italian-inspired vibe that really makes it stand out from other pizza places. The smell of fresh-baked dough and tomatoes lingers through the air as soon as you walk in the door.

The pizza itself is truly amazing. I had the “Fungo” which consisted of roasted mushrooms and truffle oil over a perfectly thin crust. The crust was crunchy on the outside yet soft and chewy on the inside – just how I like it! The toppings were flavorful and fresh, adding to the overall deliciousness of my meal.

The service staff at Azzurra Pizza are also top-notch! They are friendly, knowledgeable, and always make sure my experience was perfect. They even let me sample some of their homemade wines to pair with my meal – something that made for an even more enjoyable experience.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Sea Isle, then look no further than Azzurra Pizza! From its inviting atmosphere to its delicious food and great service staff, this restaurant definitely deserves five stars from me!

#8 Vita Bella

This small, unassuming pizza joint is my favorite place around. From the moment you walk into Vita Bella, you can tell that the owners truly care about making their customers happy. The walls are filled with photos of past customers and the staff always makes it a point to welcome each guest warmly.

The pizza is definitely the star of the show here. Never greasy or heavy, all of Vita Bella’s pizzas are cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven. The dough is made fresh daily, and there’s something for everyone on the menu — from classic margheritas to creative combinations like prosciutto and kale.

If I had to pick one favorite dish, it would be their “Best Pizza In Sea Isle” creation. This one tops a crispy crust with generous amounts of cheese, roasted vegetables, and crumbly sausage — it’s mouthwatering! I also love their homemade sauces which really bring out the flavor in every bite.

In conclusion, if you’re ever in Sea Isle and looking for great pizza at an unbeatable price then make sure you stop by Vita Bella! I promise that you won’t regret it!

#9 Fratelli’s Wood-Fired Pizzeria – Sea Isle City

This place is a wood-fired pizzeria, so the pizza has that perfect smokey flavor and crispy crust. As I bit into one of their specialties – the Margherita Pizza with San Marzano Tomatoes, Crushed Garlic, Olive Oil and Fresh Basil – I thought to myself this pizza is definitely worth writing home about.

The ingredients are fresh and flavorful, and the staff here are incredibly friendly and knowledgeable about their menu items. Plus, you can tell they take great care in preparing each pizza.

As a traveling food critic, I give Fratelli’s Wood-Fired Pizzeria – Sea Isle City my highest recommendation. If you’re ever passing through Sea Isle or looking for the best pizza in town, definitely check out this amazing spot!

#10 Phil’s Famous Pizzeria

The restaurant itself has an inviting and cozy atmosphere, with paintings of caricatures from old Italian movies on the walls. As soon as you walk into the store, the amazing aromas hit you like a wave!

When it came to the pizza, I got to experience different kinds of doughs, red sauces, and cheeses. I even got to choose my own toppings! The flavors were simply out of this world; the combination of ingredients was just perfect.

The service was also extremely polite and friendly. Our waiter explained each variety of pizza in detail, which was really helpful given that there were so many options.

All in all, Phil’s Famous Pizzeria is definitely worthy of its name. Its unique menu and fantastic taste make it truly one-of-a-kind – in my opinion, this is the best pizza in Sea Isle!

#11 Uncle Oogie’s Pizzeria & Specialty Sandwiches

Upon stepping into the restaurant, I was welcomed by a warm and inviting ambiance. The decor is modern, yet inviting and it was clear that this place has been around for a while. The menu features both pizzas and specialty sandwiches and I knew immediately that I would be in for a treat.

For my meal, I went all out with a large pepperoni pizza and one of their signature sandwiches. The pizza dough was made in-house and it had the perfect combination of crispness and chewiness, making it some of the best crust I’ve ever had! The toppings were flavorful and the pizza itself was cooked to perfection – not too charred nor undercooked. As if that wasn’t enough, they provided each one of us with unlimited refills on our drinks! What a great touch!

As for the sandwich, it featured layers upon layers of delicious meats, cheeses, veggies, sauces, and bread – all harmoniously melded together to make a truly unique experience. It was definitely something special!

At the end of the night I could tell why Uncle Oogie’s Pizzeria & Specialty Sandwiches has been around for so long; it’s easily one of the best restaurants serving up pizza in Sea Isle! With its high quality ingredients, consistent cooking techniques, friendly atmosphere, and delicious food – there simply isn’t any other place like it.

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Ocean City!

#12 Casino Steak & Pizza

I first stepped into this cozy restaurant and was immediately met with the savory aroma of fresh-baked pizza. That alone made my mouth water!

The menu is simple, but varied enough to accommodate any taste – classic pizzas like pepperoni and sausage, as well as more unconventional flavors like mac & cheese and jalapeno popper. I opted for a classic Italian style pizza, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, and mushrooms.

The pizza was cooked perfectly – the crust was golden brown and crisp on the outside but still soft on the inside. The toppings were fresh and flavorful. And the sauce was delicious – sweet and tangy just how I like it!

I washed it all down with a cold beer, of course – what else would you expect from a place called Casino Steak & Pizza?! All in all, I have to say that this is definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had in Sea Isle. If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience, then look no further than Casino Steak & Pizza!

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Fratelli’s Wood-Fired Pizzeria – Sea Isle City

Picture this: you walk into Fratelli’s, and the intoxicating smell of wood-fired goodness hits you like a hungry Godzilla. You’re immediately transported to pizza heaven, where the angels sing in perfect harmony and the crust is as crispy and delicious as you could ever dream. It’s that good, folks.

The menu is a pizza lover’s dream come true. From classic margherita to unique combinations like BBQ chicken with pineapple, there’s a pizza for every adventurous taste bud. And did I mention the toppings? They don’t skimp on those bad boys! You want extra cheese? Done. Extra pepperoni? Absolutely. They’ll even put a cherry on top if you ask nice enough. Well, maybe not a cherry, but you get the point.

Now, let’s talk about the wood-fired magic happening in their oven. The pizza chefs at Fratelli’s are like puppet masters, controlling the flames with a delicate touch. They’ve crafted a perfectly balanced crust that’s neither too thin nor too thick, with just the right touch of smoky flavor. It’s like eating a slice of heaven, but without the pearly gates and harp-playing angels. Though, you might consider starting a fan club for their pizza if you’re feeling extra enthusiastic.

So, dear fellow pizza enthusiasts, if you find yourself in lovely Cape May County, New Jersey, do yourself a favor and head straight to Fratelli’s Wood-Fired Pizzeria – Sea Isle City. Your taste buds will thank you, and you might just become a pizza evangelist spreading the good news of Fratelli’s to anyone who will listen. Have a slice, or five, for me!