THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Sea Isle City, NJ - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated August 2024 (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“Simply amazing! Perfect food, service and view. The best restaurant at the Jersey shore.”

Customers` Favorites

“I always make it a point to stop by when I'm in Sea Isle. The slices are excellent made with top notch ingredients, and they don't skimp on toppings either. I usually go for their buffalo chicken, and riccotta slices, and I haven't found another place that even comes close. I've been coming here for years, and plan to for years to come.”

Customers` Favorites

“Best Italian deli ever! Best Italian hoagie loaded with so much meat. Homemade tuna salad was so good. The hot Roast pork sandwich with broccoli rabe was so tender and delicious! Can’t wait to return!”

Customers` Favorites

“We have been coming here for many years with our kids and are so happy to have experienced this pizza for the first time this year! We ordered a plain and then came back a couple days later and ordered veggie, plain and bacon. It’s so so good, and the owner was very cool. We’ll definitely be back.”

Customers` Favorites

“So delicious. We go to the one in sea isle city nj .We also have a residence in Annapolis Md . In the Annapolis Towne Centre . Would love to see one there . There are some open spaces and there is no other walk up food type place . No other ice cream or yogurt places there . Would be great location for a playa bowls . There is a True Food going up so there’s a health food trend that could be started !!”

Customers` Favorites

“It’s refreshing to see a place that gets it. Besides the amazing seafood when there is a hiccup with their great service they more then make up for it. Great food great people what more can you ask for
Thank you”

Customers` Favorites

Customers` Favorites

“One of our favorites places. Nothing fancy, but good, creative food. Known for their hot sauce, but I enjoy their food just as much. Favorites include the wings and the pulled pork or ahi tuna tacos.”

“Not only is the food amazing but the staff makes you feel like family! ❤️”

Customers` Favorites

“Service was great. The bus boy was on top of clearing tables. Atmosphere was nice since the restaurant is on the bay. The flounder had no flavor and they forgot the crab cake. The bread with sundried tomato dipping oil was good. The Ceasar salad and side dishes were good. The fish just had no flavor. It was the server's first night and she mentioned most of the wait staff and kitchen staff are new.”

Customers` Favorites

“Excellent quality seafood and amazing customer service. Alex is the best! If she isn't already in charge of something, she should be put in charge of something and definitely given a raise. The girl knows what she is doing ! Thanks for getting our order ready!!”

Customers` Favorites

“We chose to sit outside. Service was great. Didn't love the owner/manager yelling at one of the bussers for trying to secure chairs in the wind, but.... I had spaghetti alla vongole, which was wonderful. My husband ordered the special veal chop which was quite underdone for him. Server was spectacular and brought us a replacement. For that alone, we will be back❤️”

Customers` Favorites

“AMAZING FOOD ALWAYS!!! All of their dishes are delicious.”

Customers` Favorites

“Nice place..good friendly service. Great grilled cheese!!”

Customers` Favorites

“Lou Dogs are the best!!”

“We’ve always enjoyed donuts from Maryanne’s, especially the cream filled ones. Today I picked up a special order birthday cake for my grandson‘s first birthday. It greatly exceeded our expectations. It was so cute, and absolutely delicious. No more driving back to Delco for birthday cakes for me! Highly recommend, you won’t go wrong or be disappointed.”

“We were so happy they were open late in the off season! Steve took care of a huge line with expediency and a smile. Lots of options for everyone so we all left happy! We'll be back!”

Customers` Favorites

“Best ice cream store in town! Family owned and operated. They make their own waffle cones- so good. Love the vibe there❤️”

“Let me first start with a compliment to Joe here ! I called in a day before to make sure that I could get a cake for my niece , and he confirmed the opening time was 11 am , I was early the next day for 10 minutes and surprisingly he opened the door at 1050 am and welcomed me in to sort me out ! He was way cool and patient about the questions I had and explained well , I got a few ice creams for my staff back in the office and he made all of them with a smile . When the cake was ready he was all smiles and ring me up , and of coz because of his exceptional service I got more ice cream ! DQ ! you have a winner here that represent your establishment well !”

Customers` Favorites

“Service was great. The bus boy was on top of clearing tables. Atmosphere was nice since the restaurant is on the bay. The flounder had no flavor and they forgot the crab cake. The bread with sundried tomato dipping oil was good. The Ceasar salad and side dishes were good. The fish just had no flavor. It was the server's first night and she mentioned most of the wait staff and kitchen staff are new.”

Customers` Favorites

“Outstanding service and top quality food!!! Amazing and delicious. Definitely our new go to place. Frank and his team are awesome!”

“Excellent and personable staff”

Customers` Favorites

“To put things into perspective, we drove 45 minutes just for THEIR pizza. Great family and amazing food! Be sure to try Grandma's pizza when you're there. 10/10!”

Customers` Favorites

“Pleasant staff, good food!”

“Amazing staff and a wonderful owner!! It is now our go to ice cream spot in Sea Isle City. Our family loves it so much I have to bring a tray in order to accommodate all the orders! Highly recommended from these Sea Isle residents!”

Customers` Favorites

“We went there one night for drinks with friends and had a blast! The beach chairs and sand floors were great for the beach vibe, the cornhole and giant connect four added an element of fun, the drinks were delicious and the service was great!”

“Fantastic sticky buns....but the crumb buns are without equal! Sea Isle location is a power packed store front, with the cutest, friendliest sales woman I've ever had! The flavors of the "stickies & crumbs" will have me counting the days till I get back! By the way.....did I mention the CRUMB BUNS ARE THE BEST IN THE WORLD? Dad's, become a super hero,,, bring home the goods from Mallon's!! Epic hero stuff!- bigeasy”

“Pretzels were great..will be visiting again soon!”

“Recommend everything. Great owner!”

“Dudley has the best dogs at the shore and could not be a nicer guy....he has been providing beach people with a nice greeting and super dogs for many, many years....”

Customers` Favorites

“We were blown away with the food and the service! Thanks for a great experience! We will be back!”

Customers` Favorites

Customers` Favorites

“The food was amazing and the owners are hilarious. Great service”

“best staff & ice cream! what’s not to love??”

Customers` Favorites

“Just picked up a bucket for two to share with my boyfriend for dinner and it was delicious! The bucket was a perfect portion for two with quality seafood that was cooked perfectly. The Ocean Crat special sauce on the seafood was amazing! Definitely one of the best seafood places on the island. 10/10 recommend for seafood takeout!”

Customers` Favorites

“We had the pleasure of eating at Basilicos this past weekend for the first time. The service, menu and specials were fantastic. Portions were generous and desserts added the perfect final touch.Love that it’s a BYO!”

Customers` Favorites

“Great place with delicious cuisine and friendly staff!”

Customers` Favorites

“Always happy we visited Red White & Brew!love the food, coffee and staff!”

“Andrea Trattoria catered our wedding in Sea Isle on 9/24/2022. The food was absolutely amazing! It was without a doubt the best buffet we've ever experienced. Tino worked with us to make sure we had a wide variety of apps, salads, and entrees. We requested Gulf shrimp and he was able to make that happen for us! Thank you, Tino and team at Andrea Trattoria!”

Customers` Favorites

“Stopped in on a late Tuesday morning. Friendly waitress. Clean table and kitchen area. Very tasty food. Omelette, blueberry chocolate chip pancakes and a Big Mofo (French toast). All great! Definitely going back.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Vodka Chicken Cutlet and the Respect Your Father sandwiches were both amazing! So glad we decided to check this place out after discovering it on Instagram about a week prior to opening. We will absolutely be back again!(Southampton)”

Customers` Favorites

“Wow, fantastic. Perfect temperature of roll versus filling, on the classic roll. Perfect amount of light mayo, with what seems like a house combination of celery seed and some sparing big pretzel salt crystals…. Just perfect munching overlooking the boardwalk, dunes and ocean in Ocean City boardwalk. And the lobster bisque was excellent. With the jumbo sized option on the classic rolls, there was lobster falling out of the sandwich before we could even pick it up. Just excellent.”

Customers` Favorites

“We ordered takeout; the food was amazing! The menu is diverse and the portions are large. We enjoyed the mushroom risotto, rigatoni bolognese, and the halibut special. The staff was helpful and friendly. Thank you so much!”

Customers` Favorites

“Great atmosphere, good service, tasty food.”

Customers` Favorites

“Our large group ordered hoagies to be delivered to us at the beach this weekend. The hoagies were delicious, service was friendly and prompt, and the convenience of delivery was greatly appreciated. We will definitely order from this location again! Thank you to Primos”

Customers` Favorites

“Great atmosphere, good service, tasty food.”

Customers` Favorites

“DeNunzio’s is an amazing family owned Italian restaurant. You can tell they take a lot of pride in what they do and if you’re looking for a real cheesesteak outside of Philly, then I highly recommend theirs.”

Customers` Favorites

“Have been a regular at the 'OD' for a couple years now and I've simply had enough weekend mega negative experiences here for one life time, directly connected to the music that the DJ and bands play. Always a whiny depressing self hate song Is playing. Play more super positive songs!!! Bob Marley and the latin vibe group music should be increasing. Being sober every time I'm at the OD is so cringe simply because the music selection is gay and retarded. -Rastaman”

Customers` Favorites

“Started going to Mrs. Brizzles about 7 years ago. The owner Mike & his wife are 2 of the nicest people you could ever meet. Not only are their sandwiches huge, so are their personalities. Our entire family have made it a point to get to Mrs. Brizzles while vacationing at the Jersey Shore. You will not be disappointed! Would give them 6 stars!”

Customers` Favorites

“We love eating here with our friends. The food is always fantastic and very friendly service. Even the valet guys are great! Or just pull up on your boat. Highly recommend!”